What is the IRS Independent Office of Appeals?

The IRS Independent Office of Appeals is a separate organization within the IRS that resolves tax disputes without litigation. It was formally established as an independent function by the IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 (RRA 98). Appeals is independent from IRS compliance functions — meaning the Appeals Officer assigned to your case has no connection to the Revenue Agent, Revenue Officer, or Compliance employee who made the determination you are appealing. The core mission of Appeals is to resolve tax controversies fairly and impartially, considering both the government's interest in collecting taxes and the taxpayer's right to challenge IRS determinations. Appeals handles: examination (audit) appeals, collection due process (CDP) cases, penalty appeals, Offer in Compromise appeals, employment tax appeals, and international tax appeals.

What are 'hazards of litigation' in IRS Appeals?

Hazards of litigation is the key concept in IRS Appeals. It means the Appeals Officer evaluates the probability that the IRS would lose if the case went to trial. This includes both factual hazards (How credible are the witnesses? How strong is the documentary evidence? Would a judge believe the IRS's version of events?) and legal hazards (How have courts ruled on similar issues? Is the IRS's legal position supported by precedent? Are there conflicting court decisions?). Based on this analysis, the Appeals Officer can settle the case for less than the full amount the IRS claimed — sometimes for a fraction of the proposed deficiency. Appeals Officers have broad settlement authority precisely because the IRS prefers to resolve cases at the administrative level rather than litigate in court. This gives the taxpayer meaningful leverage in settlement negotiations.

What are ex parte communications rules in IRS Appeals?

Ex parte communications between IRS Appeals and IRS compliance personnel (Revenue Agents, Revenue Officers, Collection employees) are generally prohibited. This means the compliance personnel who made the determination you are appealing generally cannot discuss your case with the Appeals Officer outside your presence. The purpose is to ensure Appeals' independence — the Appeals Officer should evaluate your case with fresh eyes, not be influenced by the compliance function's views expressed outside the record. There are limited exceptions: administrative matters, ministerial communications, and communications involving the Appeals Officer educating compliance personnel about Appeals procedures. However, communications about the strengths or weaknesses of your specific case between Appeals and Compliance outside your presence are prohibited. This firewall is a critical taxpayer protection.

IRS Independent Office of Appeals building

IRS Appeals

IRS Independent Office of Appeals: Your Right to an Independent Review

When the IRS makes a determination you disagree with — whether it is an audit finding, a penalty assessment, a lien filing, a levy action, or a rejected Offer in Compromise — you have a statutory right to an independent review by the IRS Office of Appeals. This is not asking the same person who made the decision to reconsider. Appeals is a completely separate organization within the IRS, created by Congress in the 1998 IRS Restructuring and Reform Act, with the specific mission of resolving tax disputes fairly without litigation.

Request Appeals Help Call 310-597-2254

Appeals Strategy — Free

Confidential and no obligation.

Get Your Free Tax Relief Review

A specialist will review your case and outline your options — completely free.

100% Confidential|CPA-Reviewed|Updated 2026

What the IRS Office of Appeals Handles

Examination (Audit) Appeals

When you disagree with audit findings, Appeals provides an independent review. The Appeals Officer considers hazards of litigation and can settle based on the probability the IRS would lose at trial. Appeals resolves most audit disputes without going to Tax Court.

Collection Due Process (CDP)

After receiving an LT11 (levy) or Letter 3172 (lien), you can request a CDP hearing before Appeals. The Appeals Officer reviews whether collection actions are appropriate, considers collection alternatives, and protects your right to Tax Court review.

Penalty Appeals

Appeals reviews penalty assessments and considers reasonable cause defenses, First-Time Abate eligibility, IRC 6751(b) supervisor approval requirements, and statutory exceptions. Penalties are a major area where Appeals can provide significant relief.

Offer in Compromise (OIC) Appeals

If your OIC is rejected, Appeals provides an independent review of the RCP calculation, asset valuations, expense allowances, and special circumstances. Appeals Officers can accept an offer that Collection rejected.

Employment & International Tax Appeals

Appeals handles employment tax disputes (worker classification, trust fund recovery penalties), international tax issues (transfer pricing, foreign tax credits, FBAR penalties), and other specialized areas requiring deep technical expertise.

Key Principles of IRS Appeals

Independence From Compliance

Appeals Officers have no connection to the IRS compliance function that made the determination you are appealing. This independence is mandated by statute (RRA 98) and is reinforced by ex parte communication prohibitions.

Hazards of Litigation Standard

Appeals settles cases based on the probability the IRS would lose at trial. Both factual hazards (evidence strength) and legal hazards (court precedent) are considered. This gives you meaningful leverage in settlement negotiations.

Ex Parte Communication Prohibition

IRS compliance personnel (auditors, revenue officers, etc.) cannot discuss your case with the Appeals Officer outside your presence. This firewall ensures the Appeals Officer evaluates your case with fresh, unbiased eyes.

Broad Experience Required

Appeals Officers must have broad experience in tax law, including familiarity with IRS procedures, substantive tax law, litigation hazards, and settlement negotiation. Many are former IRS Chief Counsel attorneys or senior Revenue Agents.

Ready to Take Your Case to Appeals? We Build the Strategy

Call 310-597-2254